Posted in Latest News on 12 Nov 2026
‘It is just an inherent and inevitable part of being a family lawyer from time to time,’ Cara Nuttall said when discussing the emotional strain that often comes with the role. ‘It’s not that you’re not cut out for it and it’s not that you’re wrong in any way.’
As a family partner and head of department at Brabners, Cara spends her working life supporting people through some of the most challenging periods they will ever face. Relationship breakdowns, disputes involving children and complex surrogacy cases form part of a workload that demands emotional resilience as much as legal expertise.
Despite the weight of that responsibility, she spoke about family law with an enthusiasm that was impossible to ignore. She described herself as ‘evangelical’ about the profession, joking that she sounded as though she was part of a cult whenever she discussed it.
For Cara, conversations around wellbeing begin with honesty. She believed the legal profession needs to be more open about burnout and emotional exhaustion, arguing that silence often prevents people from seeking support when they need it most.
‘People are less inclined to speak up when they feel it’s happening to them,’ she explained. ‘Or people feel that if it’s happening to them, it’s because there’s something wrong with them, or they’re doing something wrong.’
Her concerns reflect a wider issue across the profession. LawCare’s 2025 Life in the Law report found that almost 60 per cent of family law professionals reported poor mental wellbeing. Those aged between 26 and 35 recorded the highest levels of burnout, while nearly a third said they had considered leaving the profession altogether.
In family law, those pressures often take on a different dimension. Cases are rarely confined to documents and deadlines. Instead, they centre on families, homes and children, with outcomes that can have a lasting impact on people’s lives. As a result, many lawyers carry the emotional weight of their cases long after the working day has ended.

When asked whether the profession talks openly enough about trauma and burnout, Cara said progress had been made, but there was still work to do.
‘It’s getting better. And I think some teams are much stronger on it than others,’ she said. While she acknowledged that support networks within family law had improved significantly in recent years, she added that ‘there’s still quite a long way to go.’
One experience from earlier in her career has stayed with her. Shortly after guidance on wellbeing and reasonable working hours had been issued by the then President of the Family Division, a judge requested written closing submissions within an extremely short timeframe. The barrister Cara was working alongside explained that meeting the deadline would require working through the night because of other commitments. According to Cara, the judge’s response was simple: ‘So be it.’
Reflecting on the incident now, she hoped attitudes had changed.
‘I don’t think that would happen now,’ she said. ‘I hope it wouldn’t happen now.’
She was quick to point out that some cases, particularly those involving serious risk to life, would always require extraordinary effort. However, she believed one of the profession’s biggest challenges is distinguishing genuine urgency from unnecessary pressure.
‘It is such emotionally challenging work and full on,’ she said. ‘If you don’t decompress somewhere, inevitably, there are consequences, whether that’s for you, for your clients, your work.’
Much of the support she values comes from the people around her, something she believes can make a significant difference to lawyers' wellbeing and resilience. At Brabners, reflective supervision allows lawyers to regularly discuss difficult cases and concerns in a confidential environment.
‘We jokingly called it our workplace therapy,’ she said with a smile. ‘But it’s that safe space to go and talk about the things that are weighing on you and that you’re worried about.’
Cara believed many of the resources family lawyers need already exist. The challenge, she argued, is creating an environment where people feel comfortable using them. Counselling, therapy, wellbeing initiatives and organisations are available across the profession, but many lawyers continue to access them quietly, if at all.
‘Sometimes people see it as a sign of weakness, or that there’s something about them that means they can’t do the job right,’ she explained.
Instead, she believed seeking support should be viewed as both acceptable and encouraged rather than something to be hidden.
Within her own team, openness is actively encouraged. Senior lawyers speak candidly about their experiences of therapy and personal challenges, helping to normalise those conversations for younger colleagues. Everyday life is also part of the discussion. Cara laughed as she recalled telling colleagues she had accidentally shrunk her favourite jumper by washing it at 90 degrees.
‘It’s just about that reminder of, we’re all just humans, we can all have a bad day,’ she said. ‘Nobody’s nailing it.’
The team structure also plays a role. Lawyers work across different groups rather than alongside the same small number of colleagues, often making it easier to spot changes in behaviour and check in on one another. Wellbeing days are encouraged, colleagues regularly cover cases for one another and social activities are planned away from legal work.
Most importantly, Cara said she wanted her team to feel they were supporting one another rather than competing. For Cara, workplace culture is not simply about morale. It plays an important role in helping lawyers build sustainable careers in what can be an emotionally demanding area of law.
For junior lawyers encountering difficult cases for the first time, that culture can be invaluable. Cara believes the quality of support available early in a lawyer's career often shapes whether they remain in a role, a team or even the profession itself.
‘I would hope that all the juniors know that if they are having a wobble or a bad day or something’s bothering them, they can always come to us,’ she said.
Senior team members regularly share their own experiences, including professional setbacks, to remind younger colleagues that difficult periods are a normal part of any legal career.
‘I’m not saying I get it right all the time,’ she admitted. ‘But I think one of the most important things for me has been to have a team that supports each other.’
Despite the emotional demands of the job, Cara said the rewards have always outweighed the challenges.
‘I love it. I love my team. I love my work. And I love my clients.’
She said the variety of the work remained one of its greatest strengths. No two cases are ever the same and each brings an opportunity to support people through significant life events.
‘You almost always come away from a case feeling that you’ve left it better than you found it,’ she said. ‘You see people at those really low moments. And then, whether it’s months or years down the line, you often see them living their best life.’
Many of those clients have stayed with her long after proceedings ended. One client had remained in touch with her for more than a decade, and despite the challenges of the case, she remembered moments where they laughed so much they nearly fell from their chairs.
Some of the cases closest to her heart have involved surrogacy. She recalled representing a client who was initially unable to obtain a parental order because of a legal technicality. After a change in the law, the order was eventually granted. Coincidentally, Cara was wearing a bracelet gifted by that client during the interview, featuring a small charm representing the child and the journey they had shared.
‘I’ve had various clients say “you will always be part of our family story”,’ she said.
Another memorable case involved a baby born through surrogacy who was removed by social services following a serious illness shortly after birth. For a period, the family did not know if the child would survive. The baby recovered, returned home and the parental order was later granted.
‘I still get emails now, on birthdays and Christmas,’ Cara said. ‘It’s just so lovely to get pictures of these kids living such an amazing life.’
For anyone considering a career in family law, her advice was straightforward.
‘Do it, do it, you’ll never look back,’ she said with a laugh.
More seriously, she encouraged aspiring lawyers to approach the profession with an open mind. Over the years, she had seen trainees arrive convinced family law was for them only to discover otherwise, while others who reluctantly completed a placement found a genuine passion for the work. Different specialisms offer vastly different experiences, she explained, and disliking one area does not mean family law as a whole is the wrong fit.
Just as important, she said, is finding the right team. The work itself is only part of the equation, she explained. Having the right people around you and a culture that encourages openness can be just as important when building a successful career in family law.
‘It’s just finding the right home.’
Perhaps that is the clearest lesson from Cara's career. Family law can be emotionally demanding, and she believes those challenges should be discussed openly rather than hidden.
While the work itself will always come with pressures, her experience highlighted the importance of finding the right environment in which to build a career. For Cara, supportive colleagues, open conversations around wellbeing and a strong team culture have played a key role in making what can be a challenging profession both sustainable and rewarding.
‘I truly can't imagine what else I would do,’ she said. Laughing, Cara added: ‘Hopefully, if AI and robots don't take over, it's what I'll do till retirement.’